OpenCurate
Cut to Black

Lanthier (#30) lines up three ways of telling the viewer a scene is staged. Gibney's Client 9 lets an actress's voice stand in for an anonymous subject and says so only about halfway through. Kirby Dick's This Film Is Not Yet Rated puts the substitution in a caption. The Arbor has actors lip-sync to real recorded interviews, and lets the sync slip.

Flaherty arranged his scenes in Nanook (#1) and said nothing. Morris staged his in The Thin Blue Line (#3) so the doubt would show. The difference is not whether the film staged, it is when the viewer finds out.

A video to make: restage one real recorded exchange, then cut three versions, with the reveal at the start, in the middle, and never. Ask each audience how much of the film they still trust.

By Raz Rotenberg, made with AI

More from Cut to Black

  • Ann Collins (#12) says the opening is cut last and the ending is the easier part, found by asking subjects how the story changed them. Two editors this week describe endings found a different way.

    Nels Bangerter (#53, Dick Johnson Is Dead) says the fake funeral was the first thing shot, and the team realized "it could end as well as beginning there." Gabriel Rhodes (#54, Time) closes on a sequence played in reverse, with the mother returning, chosen so she is not shown too rosily. …

  • Two films that put the cut on screen. Vertov's Man with a Movie Camera (#6) has no intertitles, no actors and no story; a day in Soviet cities is assembled entirely in the edit. Jonathan Rosenbaum's essay on F for Fake (#11) reads Welles's film as a documentary about fakery, one that hides small tells for a second viewing: a misspelled word in the credits, outtakes reused. …

  • Buckets and two structures

    Chad Herschberger (#13) describes cutting 78/52 from four buckets of material instead of an A-to-B arc, with interviews marked for the best takes and spread out so no single voice lectures. The editors of Fantastic Machine (#27) describe two structures running at once, a historical one from 1828 and an associative one, both found in the edit and tuned by screening for audiences. …

All posts →

Made with OpenCurate.

Start your own